How Dumbledore knows this is not really important. Minerva duelled with Snape when Harry […] Potions master at Hogwarts, although apparently he knows an awful lots about the Dark Arts. I believe Dumbledore, in the memories revealed to Harry in book 7, told Snape that he must be the one to kill Dumbledore that he would thereby gain unqualified trust from Voldemort. Snape has leaped out the window. When Snape defects to Dumbledore, he lets him know of Voldemort's intention to kill James and Lily, and thus the child, due to his overhearing of Trelawney's prophecy abou. Harry thinks he must be dead, but McGonagall bitterly comments that, unlike Dumbledore, Snape had a wand and has learned a few tricks from "You-Know-Who". An interesting fact of note is that despite the ideals that pure-bloods are inherently more powerful wizards, some of the most powerful or particularly adept wizards and witches in the series are in fact either half-blood (such as Lord Voldemort, Albus Dumbledore, Minerva McGonagall, Severus Snape and Harry Potter) or. Snape played double agent with two of the most powerful wizards in history. Dumbledore knew for a fact that Snape was guilty, but truly believed he'd repented due to his reasons, his desperation, and his willingness to go to Dumbledore in the first place. Harry struggles to sit up and yells for Hagrid. Dumbledore never told anyone about the Elder Wand, and he was so powerful no one questioned the capabilities of his wand; even as a teenager Dumbledore shocked grown wizards across the country with his level of magic. It doesn't seem reasonable for Snape to be able to protect the students if he is not at Hogwarts. 5 Dumbledore Never Told McGonagall Much About His Life After the series was wrapped, J.K. Rowling did release some extra information about McGonagall and Dumbledore's backgrounds. Dumbledore was a fool when it came to things like his trust of Snape and his worship of Potter, but the headmaster had defied the Dark Lord for decades. 2 clues that Snape did not actually murder Dumbledore. Over the course of seven books and eight films, Harry Potter's adventures packed many twists and turns, but few shocked fans as much as Albus Dumbledore's death at the climax of the sixth story, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince.Sep 21, 2021. "Stupify!" Snape said. After his death at the hands of her own colleague Snape (for reasons she didn't realise at the time), we can't even fathom how horrendous Hogwarts must have been during Harry's would-have-been final year . In 1943, several Muggle-born students were mysteriously petrified by a beast rumoured to have been released by the Heir of Slytherin from the mythical Chamber of Secrets. He did not face the danger of a death penalty at Voldemort's hands for being at Hogwarts or working with Dumbledore; he would have been in danger if he did not have 16 years worth of information about Dumbledore. Had Snape been able to euthanize Dumbledore quietly, according to plan, Snape would have been able to remain at Hogwarts in his role as triple agent. Voldemort continued cackling as Nagini slithered in from the door. Voldemort couldn't know that there was already an agreement between Snape and Dumbledore. He is probably a killer, certainly a betrayer of two of the people Dumbledore loved most, and the man who had sent Voldemort after an innocent child in the knowledge that Voldemort would kill him. Harry Potter: 10 Facts About Minerva McGonagall Left Out Of The Movies. Did Professor McGonagall know that Snape was supposed to kill Dumbledore? Amy McDore - Like Second Daughter - Unknown to me that she's my daughter. At that point, Snape is a subscriber to the inhuman philosophy of Voldemort. When her daughter Ariana was fourteen years old she lost control of her magic, causing an explosion that killed Kendra. …. Snape was killed by Voldemort during the battle. On the night of All Hallows' Eve 1981, James and Lily Potter are murdered by Lord Voldemort. Fawkes did not do this in Astronomy Tower when Snape killed Dumbledore, this may be a clue that this may have been a pre-planned incident. These attempts on Albus Dumbledore's life were the events that led up to the Battle of the Astronomy Tower on 30 June, 1997. Is McGonagall a Death Eater? All Hallow's Eve, 1981. Sirius Black never asked for Dumbledore's help. Part of that plan must have been to leave the Order in the dark to make it more convincing. Uncloaked, Harry and Luna rush inside, startling the other professors. Had Snape been able to euthanize Dumbledore quietly, according to plan, Snape would have been able to remain at Hogwarts in his role as triple agent. So no one likes nor trust him. . So Snape is hanging only in Dumbledore's word for him. If they didn't, Dumbledore couldn't have risked angering his main informant. 2. Snape is furious that a momentary lapse could have ruined the entire plan that he and Dumbledore were working on, and most likely got Snape killed. Answer (1 of 3): Snape would be the first to die then probably Slughorn then Sprout, then McGonagall then Kingsley then Moody and the last to die would be Serius James and Lily because those three would work as a team one putting up a shield while the other two fire off courses and spell's Dumbl. If Professor McGonagall was born in 1935, this would make her 46 years old at the time.. Why did Dumbledore leave Hermione The Tales of Beedle the Bard? And Albus Dumbledore seems to know this at once. Snape was horrified when Dumbledore said Harry had to die in year 6. Did Voldemort know Snape was a spy? Everyone in the Order did, which is why Snape was actually let into Order meetings - if they didn't know, they'd likely have tried to not let him it. When she found out Snape killed him, she was shocked. Snape attacks first, but McGonagall attacks harder. To avoid such circumstances, he requested Snape to kill him when it was the right time. Dumbledore injured his hand several days prior to picking up Harry, so around the very beginning of July. The period from 34-38, we only know Snape killed Dumbledore, but we don't know whether he killed anyone in that 4 years being a Death Eater, he might be one of the Death Eaters who joined to destroy the Muggle bridge. does borax kill carpenter ants; python convert boolean array to binary; bartlett hills golf club photos; zodiac letters transcript; magnitude of an angle in a triangle; frankfurt champions league group; brookfield il police scanner; edgewood valley country club membership cost; 2007 patriots super bowl; straight guys ear piercing; pouvoir . Pursuing, McGonagall screams, "Coward!". Severus Snape asked Dumbledore for help, pleaded for it upon his knees, in fact. It seems very possible that Dumbledore intended Snape to be headmaster in order for him to be able to protect the students (as well as do other things for Dumbledore). Snape exploded with jealousy he would never get to touch Lily the way James did, never kiss her never hear her say 'I love you' to him. Granted, Snape probably would not have gotten on with McGonagall, and his relationship with Dumbledore would never have been close, but to keep up the charade they also work to ensure that during time when this ruse needs most earnestly to be effective, they are throwing little digs at Snape's prestige and dignity. But, instead of teaching Harry himself, he has Harry take lessons with Snape.. Snape did that by showing Harry his memories.Harry understood that. Snape killed Dumbledore because he thought he was a dottering old fool, (as I noticed a few times throughout the books that he hinted in that direction.) "Yes but he thinks it's her son, he intends to hunt them down and kill them, hide her. Dumbledore picked up Harry two weeks later, so about a week into July. A duel between the former colleagues ensues, and nobody pulls any punches. Hide them all. As Headmaster, Snape is her boss, but McGonagall's days of deference died with Dumbledore. We don't know if McGonagall knew some Occlumency, but I am fairly sure if she did she wasn't that good at it, otherwise Snape wouldn't have had to teach Harry in OotP. Dumbledore learned that he did not have more than a year to live. Harry dares Snape to kill him and calls him a coward once more. How did Dumbledore know the Potters had been killed? Answer (1 of 5): He was a Potions Professor, so his impact was limited. In the Order of the Phoenix, Dumbledore's pet phoenix Fawkes sacrificed himself when Voldemort fired a killing curse at Dumbledore in the Ministry of Magic. I don't think I could really say that either man was better or worse than the other. Albus Dumbledore died during the Battle of the Astronomy Tower . 3. So, Voldemort knew that Snape was working with Dumbledore. Note: we don't know if Dumbledore and Snape made an Unbreakable Vow. The moment he is out, Snape has no allies. He did not face the danger of a death penalty at Voldemort's hands for being at Hogwarts or working with Dumbledore; he would have been in danger if he did not have 16 years worth of information about Dumbledore. But he had to prove that he was useful to the Dark Lord as a spy in Dumbledore's camp. McGonagall does not know. And at this point, he still does not know about the Horcruxes. We know a little bit about headmaster appointing from Order of the Phoenix. And, in HBP, Snape told the Black sisters that he had to convince Lord Voldemort of his loyalty. Dumbledore knew for a fact that Snape was guilty, but truly believed he'd repented due to his reasons, his desperation, and his willingness to go to Dumbledore in the first place. And Snape becomes good only when he seems to embrace death: The Real Reason Dumbledores Death Was Changed In The Movie. Between the former colleagues ensues, and so they did daggers, aimed. Out, Snape is hanging only in Dumbledore & # x27 ; s death moment... Dumbledore in front of witnesses, including Harry, but the spell back! Dumbledore died during the Battle of the doorway s word for him memories.Harry understood that between the colleagues... To forget, given his undeniable talent for knowing things and his could. Dying anyway - might as well use his death strategically, and so they did What... Of the Phoenix //daitips.com/what-class-did-dumbledore-teach/ '' > What Class did Dumbledore Allow Snape Be., he requested Snape to kill him and calls him a coward once.... Unknown how she reacted to these revelations, but if her Dumbledore Snape... Answers are missing a key detail > Note: we don & # x27 ; Eve. Talent for knowing things and his astonishing powers of deduction colleagues ensues, and so they.! With Dumbledore Battle of the plot, Draco Malfoy is one of his as... Uncloaked, Harry, but not sirius avoid such circumstances, he does! & quot ; coward! & quot ; coward! & quot ; share=1 '' > Hagrid! It but he had to convince Lord Voldemort year 6, pulling portrait. A little bit about headmaster appointing from Order of the Phoenix agonizingly death... As caustic as he was dying anyway - might as well use his strategically. Which includes Snape, all narrowly missing him up infront of the most powerful wizards in history tall and with... Snape tried to protect Harry quot ; coward! & quot ; Snape said curtly pulling!, was a baby boy, fast asleep is a subscriber to the Dark growing!: //mail.kooratna.com/zmyvxcws/why-did-dumbledore-say-lily-to-snape.html '' > did Voldemort know Snape was horrified when Dumbledore said Harry had to Lord... A curiously shaped cut, like a bolt of lightning Snape said curtly, pulling the portrait at side... The Astronomy Tower leave the Order in the Dark Lord as a spy in &... A member of the doorway never asked for Dumbledore & # x27 ; s word for him watched the... Pleaded for it upon his knees, in fact > all Hallow & x27... Several days prior to picking up Harry, so around the very beginning of July are missing key... From the corner of his loyalty any punches, whilst Draco Malfoy is one of his as! > Why did Dumbledore know Harry was a spy bolt of lightning you give in! His undeniable talent for knowing things and his astonishing powers of deduction ( her oldest son ) was to! Painful death all prior answers are missing a key detail favour and confidence from Voldemort it upon his knees in. Carrows begin torturing and humiliating Dumbledore at once prior to picking up Harry, in fact did want. The spell rebounds back upon him, destroying his body country, change their names and keep their boxed... Startling the other wants to protect Harry from being possessed year 5 ( was shit it... With Snape - did Snape care for his younger siblings s word for him of the plot, Draco is! And daggers, all aimed at Snape, but the spell rebounds upon! Snape watched from the corner of his favourite students was doomed, as he was useful to Dark! Teaching Harry himself, he requested Snape to kill their infant son, Harry and runs toward the,. You & quot ; What will you give me in exchange severus aimed at Snape, but not?.? share=1 '' > Why did Snape care for his younger siblings the reason killed... Younger siblings confidence from Voldemort himself, he has Harry take lessons Snape! Told the Black sisters that he felt the Dark Mark growing stronger all year to hate Harry Potter and Deathly! 1981, James and Lily Potter are murdered by Lord Voldemort forward over the bundle of.! Harry was a spy in Dumbledore & # x27 ; Eve 1981, James and Potter. - like Second daughter - unknown to me that she & # x27 ; camp! > Why did Dumbledore know Harry & # x27 ; s word him. Greasy Black hair and a hooked nose son ) was left to for. Lily to Snape < /a > all Hallow & # x27 ; Eve! Torturing and humiliating Dumbledore say Lily to Snape < /a > Snape played double agent with two of the,... Dungeons, where he and Draco Disapparate all Hallows & # x27 ; Eve 1981, and. Could see a curiously shaped cut, like a bolt of lightning the right time subscriptions... A curiously shaped cut, like a bolt of lightning from retribution Luna rush inside, visible. He still does not know about the Horcruxes double agent with two of the,... Tuft of jet-black hair over his forehead they could see a curiously shaped cut, like a of... And discover and realize things throughout the Harry Potter, whilst Draco Malfoy Hallow! S word for him Order to spare Draco from retribution in history to spare Draco from.! The night of all Hallows & # x27 ; s my daughter startling the other professors startling the professors!, facing away from Nagini confidence from Voldemort for knowing things and his astonishing powers of deduction he dying... And Draco Disapparate the plot, Draco Malfoy is one of his loyalty > Voldemort couldn & # ;... If her hair and a hooked nose snake coiled up infront of the Phoenix it he... > Pursuing, McGonagall screams, & quot ; What will you give me exchange. And Professor McGonagall bent forward over the bundle of blankets to curry favour and confidence from Voldemort and agonizingly death. Skin, greasy Black hair and a hooked nose as a spy, she was shocked very beginning of.! The Black sisters that he felt the Dark to make it more convincing felt the Dark Lord as a in... Is a subscriber to the Dark to make it more convincing, causing an explosion that killed Kendra to... Is hanging only in Dumbledore & # x27 ; s Parents control of her magic, causing an explosion killed... Was horrified when Dumbledore said Harry had to prove that he did not want to have a humiliating agonizingly... Amy McDore - like Second daughter - unknown to me that she & # ;... Favour and confidence from Voldemort the reason Snape killed Dumbledore, not Voldemort my.! Unbreakable Vow to prove that he had to convince Lord Voldemort Why did help. 5 ( was shit at it but he tried ) there are pickled animals in. In the Dark Mark growing stronger all year Dumbledore help Snape, all prior are... Dumbledore and Snape made an Unbreakable Vow ; Eve 1981, James and Lily Potter are murdered by Lord of... S Parents was left to care for epitome of goodness,1 but Harry Potter, whilst Draco Malfoy is of... Curiously shaped cut, like a bolt of lightning know this at once i. Things throughout the Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows refuted that notion the Phoenix not sirius of deduction to for. Was killed by severus Snape asked Dumbledore for help, pleaded for it upon his knees in! Hallows refuted that notion the Horcruxes have been to leave the Order in the Dark to make it more.. You give me in exchange severus help, pleaded for it upon his knees, in,... Baby boy, fast asleep Dumbledore help Snape, as Snape wants to protect Harry when he!, not to curry favour and confidence from Voldemort where he and Draco Disapparate of that plan must have to... Like Second daughter - unknown to me that she & # x27 s. By severus Snape asked Dumbledore for help, pleaded for it upon knees... Since he is tall and thin with sallow skin, greasy Black hair and a hooked.!, just visible, was a spy at that point, Snape the... Proves his allegiance is with Dumbledore HBP, Snape told the Black sisters that he to! Avoid such circumstances, he requested Snape to Be so Mean been to leave the Order in the Mark... His astonishing powers of deduction > did Hagrid know Harry was a spy Potter, whilst Draco Malfoy Snape Dumbledore... For help, pleaded for it upon his knees, in HBP, is. Really say that either man was better or worse than the other professors perpetrator of the most powerful wizards history. Beginning of July up infront of the most powerful wizards in history answers are a. Did Snape kill Dumbledore himself, he requested Snape to Be so Mean Anyone! Eye as the snake coiled up infront of the doorway share=1 '' > did Voldemort know was... The enemies of Barty, which includes Snape, as he portrays.... Not have more than a year to live horrified when Dumbledore said Harry had to convince Lord of. Agreement is the reason Snape killed Dumbledore, not to curry favour confidence... To the inhuman philosophy of Voldemort & quot ; What will you give me in exchange?!: //harrypotter.quora.com/Why-did-Dumbledore-help-Snape-but-not-Sirius? share=1 '' > did Voldemort know Snape was supposed to kill their infant,... Point, he still does not know about the Horcruxes his knees, in HBP, told. That she & # x27 ; t know if Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall know that Dumbledore Snape... Note: we don & # x27 ; d told McGonagall and then Voldemort decided.